HV Mfg Magazine – Fall 2026 Issue


Workforce Development

Are You Hiring for Skills or Keywords?
Skills Based Hiring Broadens the Candidate Pool and Improves Your Chances of Finding the Right Fit

Talent illustration graphic

Your most experienced people are getting closer to retirement, and some of what they know isn’t written down anywhere. Every open seat shows up as overtime, a late shipment, or work you had to turn down. Every bad hire costs you and your team time, energy and resources. And, to top it all off, the resumes coming in are harder to trust than ever – resumes are so cluttered with AI-generated content that it’s nearly impossible to tell real experience from noise.

When resumes stop telling you the truth, keywords and job titles stop being useful signals. What someone can actually do becomes the only thing worth screening for.

That’s the idea behind skills-based hiring. Here’s what it looks like, with an example.

A job that looks simple on paper

Say you want to hire a procurement professional who will also support customer service as needed. They need to be comfortable managing RFQs to suppliers, placing purchase orders, working with your supplier base to ensure timely delivery, and preparing freight documentation. Where it makes sense, you’d like them to pursue cost-saving opportunities.

A job description written with this language will attract candidates who look for “Supply Chain,” “Procurement,” or “Logistics” roles.

But there’s a good chance you’ll mostly attract business analysts, warehouse supervisors, and people who manage these processes but don’t do the work day to day. They won’t be comfortable in the weeds of an Excel-based purchase order, and that’s most of the job.

A skills-based approach starts by going back to fundamentals. What does this person need to be able to do expertly to get the job done? What does it actually mean to manage purchase orders and RFQs and handle freight documentation?

After reviewing the day-to-day work of your procurement team, you realize you need someone with accuracy and follow-through on documents. Someone who keeps paper moving, who either knows the relevant details on a customer on the spot or knows where to look, and who transcribes information without errors.

So you write a job description that leads with that: proactive information seeking, accuracy, and document management, instead of procurement titles and keywords.

You’ll probably still find purchasing agents. But you may also find a data entry specialist, a paralegal who churns through information all day, or a store manager who keeps meticulous inventory records. You’re not hiring by keyword anymore, but competence.

That’s skills-based hiring: screening people by what they’ve proven they can do, rather than by proxies like degree, industry, or title. It’s a creative, scrappy way of hiring. You identify the fundamental abilities a job requires, then build a search that finds the people who have them.

Does it work?

This is more than just a hunch. Decades of research on hiring show that structured interviews and work samples are among the best predictors of how someone will perform on the job (Sackett et al., 2022). Years of experience, on the other hand, predicts surprisingly little (Van Iddekinge et al., 2019).

Why most companies don’t see results

So what’s the catch? Saying it and doing it are different things.

When Harvard Business School and the Burning Glass Institute looked at what happened after companies dropped degree requirements, most kept hiring the same people they always had. Removing a filter didn’t change who got hired. The companies that saw real change did the unglamorous work: figuring out what each role really requires and rebuilding how they screen for it.

That work is a lift.

In my own practice, I use interviews, employee shadowing, market research, and O*NET data to build a competency framework for each role, then test it against real applications and keep refining it.

Skills Over Resumes Editorial Collage

Start with one job posting

You can start smaller than that. Pull the posting for the role that’s been hardest to fill. Circle every job title, industry term, and years-of-experience requirement. For each one, ask whether someone without it could still do the work. Every time the answer is yes, you’ve widened your pool without raising your pay.

“One thing that manufacturers know is evolution,”

Here’s the good news: you don’t need to take the rest of this on yourself.

Through the Council of Industry’s Workforce & Talent Solutions Pilot, manufacturers can work directly with us to take a closer look at their workforce challenges and hard-to-fill roles. We’ll work together to assess your hiring needs, build an action plan around the roles you need to fill, and put it into practice. From strengthening job descriptions and candidate screening strategies to connecting you with apprenticeships, internships, job boards, education and workforce partners, we’re here to help you find and build the talent you need.

About the Author

Sameea Butt is the founder of Built By Skill and serves as the Council of Industry’s Workforce & Talent Solutions Specialist. She brings more than a decade of experience in workforce development, graduate-level training in workforce policy, and expertise in data-driven, skills-based hiring. Through the Council’s Workforce & Talent Solutions Pilot, Sameea works directly with Hudson Valley manufacturers to identify what is getting in the way of hiring, define the skills their jobs actually require, strengthen how they attract and assess candidates, and build more effective talent pipelines.


Listen to this story on YouTube

Sameea Butt

Sameea Butt is the Council of Industry’s Workforce & Talent Solutions Specialist. She is also the founder of Built by Skill.